More oil royalty, not Petronas projects
Some Barisan Nasional leaders have a myopic view of Petronas' contributions to Sabah.
KOTA KINABALU September 7, 2011: Sabah Barisan Nasional assemblyman Karim Bujang has come under heavy attack for saying that it is better to have more Petronas projects in Sabah than increasing the state’s oil royalty.
Karim, who is Bongawan state assemblyman, had said that Petronas had “done much” and had contributed “significantly” to the state economy.
He claimed Petronas had spent billions of ringgit to implement various projects in Sabah that directly benefit the people, including local contractors as well as the economic spin-offs which were enjoyed by locals.
But local leaders here disagree and are of the opinion that Karim is talking rubbish.
Kota Kinabalu MP Hiew King Cheu ticked off Karim over his “short-sighted and narrow” views.
“Maybe, Karim cannot see the significance of having higher royalty rate from the current 5% to 20%.
“Petronas is not doing Sabah a favour. The projects put up by Petronas in the state are definitely in the clauses in the agreement signed a long time ago.
“Sabahans deserved it anyway. It is our right to enjoy all the developments and benefits from it (agreement).
“But the question here is, why didn’t we see all these projects being put up in the past decades? Was Petronas not aware of these terms in the agreement before?” he asked.
Hiew said any increase in the royalty rate on oil and gas will increase the revenue of the state.
“This increased revenue will surely out-beat the project costs in the long run,” he said, adding that over the past decades Sabah had only received RM5.3 billion from Petronas.
No benefit from projects
Many here feel that Sabah, as the largest gas producer and the fourth largest crude oil producer in the country, has been shortchanged.
They believe that Petronas should do more for the state.
Hiew said if the royalty rate is increased to 20%, then Sabahans will enjoy an instant injection of state fund and the state financial status will then improve.
“The most important point now is to review Petronas royalty agreement. If Petronas brings projects into Sabah, can the local people see some instant benefits?
“I doubt it… maybe a few of the BN contractors and other expatriate contractors can get jobs.
“How long do we have to wait for a return from these projects, another five or 10 years?
“By then our oilfields may have already run dry,” he said, adding that the scenario was not impossible, especially when Sabah’s oilfields are not in the form of a seam layer but pocketed and spread out in the sea.
He said the extraction cost in such situations would be much higher and as such, it was sometimes not economical to work such fields.
“Some of the oilfields have already closed down. This means that Sabah will have to make the best use of the time to gain better royalty rates now or never, and before the oil and gas ran out eventually.
“We cannot allow this to go on,” he said.
Petronas neglected Sabah
Hiew is not alone in his views.
Last month, another opposition member Dr Roland Chia accused Petronas, which incidentally derived the bulk of its wealth from Sabah, of spending lavishly on projects in the peninsula while ignoring Sabah.
Sabah, he said, was right at the bottom in the country’s poverty index.
Chia, who is Sabah PKR secretary, said Petronas had neglected its corporate social responsibility (CSR) to Sabah.
Instead, the oil company was reportedly spending billions of ringgit on sponsoring sports cars to participate in the F1 circuit, and financing the elite Prince Court Medical Centre (PCMC) in Kuala Lumpur.
Critics have complained that Petronas spent RM544 million on PCMC and this contrasted with the RM47 million the company spent over the last 36 years (from 1975 to 2011) on its Education Sponsorship Programme (PESP) in Sabah, which works out to RM1.3 million a year
Sabah has the highest poverty rate, with 42% of the nation’s poor living in Sabah.
-----
LIMITED YEARLY ALLOCATION WAS NOT ENOUGH TO SERVE MORE THAN 50 VILLAGES IN HIS AREA - SAIRIN
UNTUNG BERSIH TAHUN KEWANGAN 3 BULAN PERTAMA PETRONAS NAIK KEPADA RM21.7 BILLION
It is best to have more projects and at the same time increases the oil royalties.
BalasPadamHope that Petronas will help Sabah develop our oil and gas industry.
BalasPadamSabah memerlukan royalti minyak lebih dan project dari petrona. Sabah patut mendapatnya.
BalasPadamprojek dan royalti, dua-dua pun ada kebaikannya. apa pun, apa yang penting pastikan petronas tidak mengabaikan tanggungjawab kepada Sabah.
BalasPadamkemudian royalti itu digunakan untuk apa? untuk pembangunan juga kan? mesti royalti itu digunakan untuk melaksanakan projek.. jadi kira sama juga dengan projek yang hendak di salurkan oleh petronas ke negeri ini.
BalasPadamdulu dia mahu petronas laksanakan lebih banyak projek di Sabah, bila petronas buat, dia tukar pula konon lebihkan royalti dan kurangkan projek.. nanti besok2 bila langsung tidak ada projek dia pula yang bising.. begitu la sikap pembangkang di negara ini..
BalasPadamdiharap projek Petronas di Sabah mengutamakan penduduk tempatan Sabah dan tuntutan kenaikan royalti 20% diluluskan. kedua2 ini perlu untuk pembangunan Sabah.
BalasPadampemimpin2 di Sabah harus memperjuangkan apa yang sebenarnya milik dan hak rakyat Sabah.
BalasPadamsaya rasa satu perkara dulu yg perlu kena improved sebelum Sabah boleh dapatkan royalti 20% itu....tingkatkan kecekapan di jabatan2 kerajaan negeri & implementasi program2 kerajaan...bukan apa, untuk mengelakkan pembaziran bah :)
BalasPadamBetter both is important. Project by petronas and the royalty from oil and gas in Sabah.
BalasPadamRoyalti penting juga kan. Tapi projek petronas penting juga. Bah biarkan saja pihak kerajaan yang menentukan dan membuat perbincangan dengan pihak petronas mengenai masalah ini.
BalasPadam"Petronas is not doing Sabah a favour. The projects put up by Petronas in the state are definitely in the clauses in the agreement signed a long time ago. Sabahans deserved it anyway. It is our right to enjoy all the developments and benefits from it (agreement)."
BalasPadamIf Petronas's project in Sabah is one of the requirement terms in the agreement, nothing we can argue about. Meaning, the have no relation between the project and increasing the loyalties to 20%. It's right where Sabah deserve more.
Petronas seharus membaca keperluan and permintaan semua rakyat Sabah. Tuntutan 20% adalah amat adil dan ia penting untuk pembangunan ekonomi negeri Sabah.
BalasPadam"Some of the oilfields have already closed down. This means that Sabah will have to make the best use of the time to gain better royalty rates now or never, and before the oil and gas ran out eventually."
BalasPadamSepatutnya pertambahan loyalties tidak harus dituntut tetapi pihak Petronas yang perlu buat adjustment sendiri selepas berpuluh-puluh tahun.
"if the royalty rate is increased to 20%, then Sabahans will enjoy an instant injection of state fund and the state financial status will then improve."
BalasPadamBetul kata beliau, loyalties tersebut akan membekalkan cukup bekalan kewangan untuk negeri Sabah untuk projek pembangunan dan perkembangan yang berterusan yang akan memanfaatkan lebih banyak rakyat Sabah.
It's right time and we urge that Petronas to review, restructure the policy and terms and implement so that it's benefit more to the people.
BalasPadamlebih projek dan royalti dinaikan - kedua2nya amat perlu memandangkan Sabah masih di tahap termiskin di Malaysia
BalasPadam“This increased revenue will surely out-beat the project costs in the long run,” - betul
BalasPadamIni sememangnya adalah hak Sabah untuk menikmati semua perkembangan dan faedah yang telah dijanjikan oleh Petronas dan permintaan kenaikan royalti memang wajar
BalasPadamInstead, the oil company was reportedly spending billions of ringgit on sponsoring sports cars to participate in the F1 circuit, and financing the elite Prince Court Medical Centre (PCMC) in Kuala Lumpur.
BalasPadamif they can spent so much...sure 20% royalties is affordable
Some of the oilfields have already closed down. This means that Sabah will have to make the best use of the time to gain better royalty rates now or never, and before the oil and gas ran out eventually - betul, kekayaan itu suatu hari akan pupus juga, jadi bila lagi kalau bukan sekarang?
BalasPadamTidak dapat dinafikan bhw banyak projek dari Petronas di Sabah. Ini merupakan syarat dalam agreement. Topik yang dibincangkan sekarang adalah tambahan 20% loyalties, ini tidak harus mengelirukannya. Harap Petronas dapat membuat yang terbaik untuk semua orang Sabahan.
BalasPadamThese are "revenue" that belong to all Sabahan, we have to strike for the additional loyalties.
BalasPadamBerapa banyak bekalan minyak yang ada? Jika tidak bertambah sekarang, bila pula masanya? Pihak Petronas seharus bertimbang rasa terhadap rakyat Sabah ni.
BalasPadamAdakah tambahan loyalties dilaksanakan bermaksud projek Petronas akan makin kurang dan tiada? Yang lebih menggalakkan, laksanakan kedua-dua perkara ini supaya rakyat Sabah menikmati perkembangan yang lebih pesat dan berterusan juga.
BalasPadamHarap semua pemimpin dan parti komponen dapat bekerja-sama dan sebulat suara untuk memperjuangkan yang terbaik untuk kami. 20% loyalties cukup mengubah keadaan ekonomi Sabah dan harap masalah kemiskinan juga dapat diselesaikan.
BalasPadamWe can give PETRONAS another chance but at the same time increase the oil royalty too.
BalasPadamIts true that PETRONAS has neglected Sabah, hope there'a an answer soon.
BalasPadamnow the BN leaders have different opinions, might be the reason they have really look into this matter.
BalasPadamwe should go for increased royalty, we can't guarantee anything good from PETRONAS anymore.
BalasPadam